Butter vs. plant oil: Striking the right balance for better living

There’s something comforting about the sizzle of butter in a hot pan. That golden aroma, the richness it brings—it’s been a kitchen favourite for generations. On the other hand, plant oils have become the go-to choice for anyone aiming for a heart-friendly lifestyle. But when you're trying to pick the healthier choice for staying well over time, which one really belongs on your plate? It’s not just about counting calories or reading labels. It’s about knowing what your body needs and how different fats can affect things like ageing, energy, and your overall health in very different ways.

The case for butter
Butter gets its charm from its simplicity. It’s made by churning cream, and that’s about it. It has a rich dose of saturated fats, which were once considered the villain of heart health. But new research is a bit kinder, saying it’s not all bad, especially when eaten in moderation. Butter also provides important fat-soluble vitamins like A, D, E, and K. It also contains butyrate, a compound that can support gut health and help reduce inflammation when eaten in small amounts.

Butter is usually less processed than many oils, which makes it a good choice for those who like natural, traditional ingredients. In Indian homes, it’s often added in small amounts for its taste and cultural value, especially while cooking or finishing dishes.

Why plant oils became popular

Plant oils like sunflower, olive, mustard, sesame, and groundnut are lighter and healthier. They have more unsaturated fats—both monounsaturated and polyunsaturated—that are good for the heart. These fats help control cholesterol, support brain health, and lower inflammation, making them great for long-term wellness.

Cold-pressed or extra virgin versions are even better, as they retain antioxidants and nutrients that support everything from skin elasticity to joint health. Oils like mustard or sesame also offer a natural antibacterial quality, which is why they’ve been used in Indian kitchens and traditional remedies for years.

It’s not just what you eat, but how much and how often

Neither butter nor oil is the enemy—excess is. Overloading any fat, even the healthy kind, can trouble your digestion and put extra strain on the heart. But picking the right fat for each meal can really help. Ghee or butter works well for a slow-cooked dal or a light tadka, while plant oils are better for sautéing veggies or tossing into salads. One major benefit of rotating between different oils and fats is that you give your body a wider range of nutrients. Just like you wouldn’t wear the same outfit every day, your body likes variety in fats too.

Finding your balance

If your goal is long-term health, clearer skin, better energy, and fewer inflammation issues as you age, then plant oils tend to offer more overall protection. They’re lighter, friendlier to your arteries, and blend well with a variety of cuisines and cooking methods. But that doesn’t mean you have to completely avoid butter. Used in small amounts, it adds both flavour and nutrition with its classic, rich taste.


Instead of taking sides, the smarter path is to understand where each fat fits into your lifestyle. Butter brings warmth and satisfaction when used thoughtfully. Plant oils offer flexibility and long-term support when chosen well and not overly refined. So, the next time you’re at the stove, you don’t have to choose one forever. Just choose wisely for the moment. Your body—and your taste buds—will thank you either way.

Video